• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Bagel Pantry

Bagel Pantry, located in Metuchen, NJ, is a beloved bagel spot known for its fresh, delicious bagels. Customers rave about the wide variety of cream cheese spreads, with standout options like jalapeño and sundried tomato. The service is fast and friendly, with a quick turnaround for orders. The cozy atmosphere and attentive staff make it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. If you're a bagel enthusiast seeking a satisfying and flavorful experience, Bagel Pantry is the place to be. Don't miss out on their savory grill menu and specialty cream cheese spreads that add a unique twist to your classic bagel experience.

LOCATIONS

Located in Metuchen, NJ, Bagel Pantry is a must-visit for all bagel enthusiasts. This cozy bagel spot offers a variety of options that cater to both vegetarians and meat lovers alike. The reviews from satisfied customers speak for themselves, highlighting the exceptional quality of their hot and fresh bagels.

One customer raved about the delicious bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on a toasted egg bagel, while another praised the jalapeño cream cheese for its stellar flavor with a nice kick. With a menu that includes unique options like confetti cream cheese and sundried tomato spread, Bagel Pantry stands out as a Central Jersey bagel hot spot.

The fast and friendly service at Bagel Pantry ensures a quick turnaround, allowing customers to enjoy their meal without waiting too long. Despite the busy atmosphere, the attentive staff and efficient system keep things running smoothly.

Whether you're a fan of savory or sweet flavors, Bagel Pantry has something to satisfy your cravings. From classic bagels with cream cheese to specialty sandwiches like the Turkey BLT, there's no shortage of tasty options to choose from. Don't forget to pair your meal with a refreshing Joe's Lemonade for the perfect combination.

Overall, Bagel Pantry offers a cozy and casual dining experience with top-notch bagels and friendly service. If you're in the area, be sure to stop by and indulge in the delicious offerings at this beloved bagel joint.

START YOUR REVIEW OF Bagel Pantry
John W.
John W.

Best hot bagels around. We drive 15 minutes to get there because the bagels are worth the ride. They open early so we go early! Very fast service, great selection.

Alex N.
Alex N.

Stopped here for a quick bite this morning. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a toasted egg bagel with butter. I didn't have to wait long for it either. The bagel was very fresh and soft. The sandwich in whole was very good. The bagel spot could use a bit more of a menu of breakfast items when walking in. I saw some stuff for some sandwiches but I did not see much of a breakfast menu. I just placed an order for the sandwich is wanted. But that's about it. I would come back and grab breakfast here again.

Inquiring M.
Inquiring M.

Amazing bagels.. service is kool.. ultimately it's a nice low key deli with really great bagels. I like coming here and would suggest it to others who aren't familiar with the area.. I dare to say they have the best bagels in town..but they have other stuff too that's not too shabby either. It can get packed on weekends and early mornings, so clearly they're doing something right! Inside is low key seedy but I doubt people go there for the ambiance.

Tammie D.
Tammie D.

Second time at this location and no disappointment. First time the line was out the door so that right there told me this place was solid. The guys move pretty quick so that's a good thing. This time no line so it was perfect and babe and I both ordered a Turkey BLT and it was delish. Inside had a few tables as well as outside if you wanted to dine in. I order to go both times just my preference. Oh and I'm always leaving with a Joe's Lemonade lol.

Tiffany C.
Tiffany C.

Pretty solid bagels. Got a jalapeño cream cheese on a toasted whole wheat bagel. Hubby got a veggie cream cheese on an everything bagel. The jalapeño cream cheese was stellar and I hadn't found a good spot with good jalapeño cream cheese in NJ until now. It's pickled jalapeño and it makes allll the difference. Nice little kick. The veggie one is good too and has some lettuce in it which was unexpected but very good. This place definitely slaps. You get in line to order at the register, and the line can be long. The parking lot gets full quickly but the customers are mostly for pick up so they're in and out quickly. The line moves fast. They have a good system and I definitely dig it. The guys are super nice and attentive. As a New Yorker, this place will be my go to in the neighborhood!

Gerald S.
Gerald S.

Busy bagel joint in the heart of Edison. Bagels are denser than I prefer, but still a good mastication. The variety of cream cheese spreads is greater than average (Confetti cream cheese? Are you kidding me!?), but I found my veggie cream cheese to be superior to many I have tried elsewhere. Service is fast and friendly. I was in the shop less than 5 minutes with bag in hand and out the back door into the parking lot. If they would try a bit less kneading to allow more air pockets in the dough, they would likely hit my preferred texture, but who am I to debate their success? Besides, many folk like it this way.

Shawna M.
Shawna M.

A small place, but solid options and a quick turn around to get your order. I ordered the pumpernickel bagel with garlic herb cream cheese and added onion and cucumber. Overall it was a nice option that hit the spot. This is close in location to family so we typically get bagels and sandwiches when town.

Aimee C.
Aimee C.

This is THE Central Jersey bagel spot! I remember the first time I was introduced to this place and was amazed that I was missing out onbsome place so close to home. They always have fresh bagels, and I am a classic lady who loves her sundried tomato spread and everything bagel. The bagels are the perfect chewy balance with a nice crust to it. They have plenty of savory options, with their sliced lox with cream cheese being a top hit as well. Don't sleep on the grill menu either, as it probably is the best bang fod your buck options around. If you are more of a sweets person, they have plenty of specialty cream cheese spreads that are sweet as well. Service is immaculate here as they have about 4-5 people constantly helping out the customers, and they just rotate which cash register they are on based on what is available. Cash does save you an extra credit card fee here. The parking lot is small, but everyone is in and out so quickly, even if there is a line out the door, you won't be waiting more than 20 minutes. It is a very casual place that is mostly for takeout, but you have some seating available there as well if you are headed out on a lil roadtrip or making a pitstop.

Zo M.
Zo M.

Couldn't make it to NJ without a stop to The Bagel Pantry. The smell of hot, fresh and delicious bagels emits as you walk in the door. The service was courteous, and our wait was less than 2 minutes. They even allowed us to do a half and half cream cheese half apple/ pie cream cheese container. ( Yes...was curious about how that would taste on my plain bagel even though my yelpie said that was blasphemy. ) Small quaint bagel shop right outside main street . Absolutely will be back.